Quantum ‘Ghost Imaging’ Reveals the Dark Side of Plants

Entanglement lets researchers watch plants in action without disruptive visible light

A plant is in one spotlight while its shadow is visible in another spotlight

Thomas Fuchs

Join Our Community of Science Lovers!

Imagine watching a time-­­lapse video of a garden you had filmed over the course of a year: you’d see details of flowers transitioning from day to night and season to season. Scientists would love to watch similar transitions on a molecular scale, but the intense light used to snap microscopic pictures of plants disrupts the processes biologists want to observe—especially at night. In the journal Optica, physicist Duncan Ryan of Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) and his colleagues recently demonstrated a tool for imaging live plant tissues while exposing them to less light than they’d receive under the stars.

A technique called ghost imaging, first demonstrated in 1995, involves splitting a light source to create two streams of photons with different wavelengths at precisely the same times and locations. Each pair of photons is entangled—a quantum phenomenon that allows researchers to infer information about one particle in a set by measuring the other. Thus, a sample can be probed at one wavelength and imaged at another.

For plants, that means researchers can record visible-light photons, whose position can be measured accurately, and get knowledge about infrared photons that interact with water-rich molecules important to biological functions in the plants. In the new study, the team directed a stream of infrared photons at a plant in a transparent box with a photon counter behind it, and at the same time they aimed those particles’ visible counterparts at an empty box at the same distance with a multipixel camera behind it. Each visible photon directed at the empty box hit a pixel and was detected in its exact location—a measurement with much more precision than an infrared camera could achieve. Meanwhile the infrared photons traveled to the plant box, but not all of them were counted: the plant absorbed some percentage of photons at a given spot. A computer logged the position of a pixel only when a photon hit both the camera and the counter simultaneously, revealing how much infrared light made it through each point. This way, the researchers could construct an image of a leaf using photons that never touched it, essentially forming an infrared image on a visible camera. “It’s like a game of Battleship,” Ryan says.


On supporting science journalism

If you're enjoying this article, consider supporting our award-winning journalism by subscribing. By purchasing a subscription you are helping to ensure the future of impactful stories about the discoveries and ideas shaping our world today.


Ghost imaging has proved successful in capturing pictures of simpler test designs. But for low-­light-­transmission samples such as plants, microscopic features often differ in absorption by just a few percent. The new study was possible because of an extremely sensitive detector developed at LANL that tracks the arrival of each infrared photon with trillionth-­of-­a-­second precision—letting the scientists map leaf tissues and peer into live plants’ nighttime activities. “We saw [leaf pores called] stomata closing as the plants reacted to darkness,” Ryan says.

Ghost imaging “creates possibilities for long-timescale dynamic imaging that does not damage live samples,” says laser spectroscopy and quantum optics researcher Audrey Eshun of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, who calls the new investigation a “truly innovative study.”

These kinds of observations make it possible to track how plants use water and sunlight throughout their circadian cycle. “We’re watching plants react to their environment,” Ryan says, “and not to our observations of them.”

Rachel Berkowitz is a freelance science writer and a corresponding editor for Physics Magazine. She is based in Vancouver, British Columbia, and Eastsound, Wash.

More by Rachel Berkowitz
Scientific American Magazine Vol 331 Issue 5This article was originally published with the title “Ghost Image” in Scientific American Magazine Vol. 331 No. 5 (), p. 19
doi:10.1038/scientificamerican122024-3Kh9Lev5GkuqQ2YCyImLaY