Listen to the Astonishing ‘Chirp’ of Two Black Holes Merging

Some of the most violent cosmic collisions occur silently in the vacuum of space, but with the right instrumental ears, we can still hear it happen. Here’s how.

Join Our Community of Science Lovers!

When two black holes slam together, they don’t make a sound. And yet, this is what we hear if we listen closely.

[CLIP: Black hole “chirp”]

Let’s listen again. 

[CLIP: Black hole “chirp”]

That “chirp” is what we heard from two black holes that slammed together about a billion light-years from Earth. The tone rises as they spiral closer together, and abruptly stops when they merge.

But sound can’t travel through the vacuum of space. So what exactly are we hearing?

Each of these black holes weighs as much as several stars; hefty enough that as they pass through space they make waves— gravitational waves, specifically.   

These waves are undulations in the fabric of spacetime that fan outwards at the speed of light, like ripples on a cosmic pond. 

Albert Einstein predicted this phenomenon in 1916, based on his theory of general relativity, but was skeptical that gravitational waves could ever be detected.

Even the strong ones from colliding black holes produce ripples roughly a thousandth the size of a proton.

It took almost a century for scientists to prove him wrong. 

Today they have built–and are expanding–a global network of observatories that has so far detected gravitational waves from about 100 cosmic collisions. 

Recorded, analyzed, and converted to sound, each one’s jostling of spacetime becomes its own distinctive, data-rich “chirp.”

Let’s listen again: 

[CLIP: Black hole “chirp”]

That long, low buildup is a sign of a slower, more sedate merger from relatively lightweight in-spiraling black holes.

A more abrupt chirp, like this: [CLIP: Black hole “chirp”]

is a sign of a faster merger of heavier black holes…

In this case a pair that combined to form one over 80 times the mass of our Sun.

Now, after a long hiatus for upgrades and the COVID pandemic, the world’s gravitational-wave observatories are tuning back in to this celestial symphony

Gravitational wave observatories don’t have mirrors or lenses like normal telescopes.

Instead they use lasers beamed down long tunnels, laid out like L’s, with two arms laying flat against the ground. 

Bounced between mirrors at the ends of each arm, the lasers act like violin strings, producing slightly different frequencies as their paths through space are stretched or contracted by passing gravitational waves. 

Shorten the laser and just like a violin string, you get a higher pitch. Lengthen it and you get a lower pitch. Convert all this laser vibrato to sound, and you can even hear black holes collide with a “chirp.”

Scientists have built a number of these laser-based ears around the globe to listen to gravitational waves from cosmic sources. 

One, called LIGO, has two detectors–one in Hanford, Washington and another in  Livingston, Louisiana. 

There’s also the VIRGO observatory near Pisa, Italy, and the KAGRA detector in Hida, Japan. 

Another detector is scheduled to be built in India.

Cross-checking between these observatories confirms each event is more than random noise; if the same ripples appear in each one, they must come from somewhere in the sky.

Timestamping a wave’s exact arrival time in each arm of an observatory–and at each different observatory around the world–helps pinpoint the wave’s direction and source location.

And the chirps picked up by these detectors can sometimes reveal much more than the final moments of merging massive bodies. 

If astronomers get lucky enough to detect both gravitational waves and light from some celestial smash-up as happened in 2017 with a neutron-star merger called GW170817.

That rich dataset allows them to measure the expansion rate of the universe and perform better tests of Einstein’s general relativity. 

GW170817 even showed scientists how much gold, platinum and other heavy metals these sorts of high-energy explosions hurl into the cosmos.

Currently, there are 93 confirmed mergers. During the next 18 months, astrophysicists hope to double their catalog of crashes, turning once-rare chirps into a cosmic chorus–a growing soundscape of the universe’s most epochal–and otherwise silent–collisions.

Dan Garisto is a freelance science journalist.

More by Dan Garisto

Jason Drakeford is a documentary filmmaker, video journalist and educator telling true, impactful stories with motion graphics and cinematic visuals.

More by Jason Drakeford

Lee Billings is a science journalist specializing in astronomy, physics, planetary science, and spaceflight, and is a senior editor at Scientific American. He is the author of a critically acclaimed book, Five Billion Years of Solitude: the Search for Life Among the Stars, which in 2014 won a Science Communication Award from the American Institute of Physics. In addition to his work for Scientific American, Billings's writing has appeared in the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal, the Boston Globe, Wired, New Scientist, Popular Science, and many other publications. A dynamic public speaker, Billings has given invited talks for NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory and Google, and has served as M.C. for events held by National Geographic, the Breakthrough Prize Foundation, Pioneer Works, and various other organizations.

Billings joined Scientific American in 2014, and previously worked as a staff editor at SEED magazine. He holds a B.A. in journalism from the University of Minnesota.

More by Lee Billings

Jeff DelViscio is currently chief multimedia editor/executive producer at Scientific American. He is former director of multimedia at STAT, where he oversaw all visual, audio and interactive journalism. Before that, he spent more than eight years at the New York Times, where he worked on five different desks across the paper. He holds dual master's degrees from Columbia University in journalism and in earth and environmental sciences. He has worked aboard oceanographic research vessels and tracked money and politics in science from Washington, D.C. He was a Knight Science Journalism Fellow at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 2018. His work has won numerous awards, including two News and Documentary Emmy Awards.

More by Jeffery DelViscio